True or faux. Do the richest 10% consume 10 times more fuel than the poorest 10%?

A reduction that favors the wealthy? Bruno Le Maire declared himself, on Saturday 23 July, Within its framework, the discount of fuel costs by 30 cents is in favor of financing by the state Amendment of Finance Bill. however The justification of those exemptions meant to battle inflation is debated. At situation: the spending habits of prosperous households for whom fuel costs have fallen “Enjoy some more, Because they drive more, often with greater automobiles.”In the phrases of Eric Worth, MP for Majority, In LCI.

On Twitter, the affiliation Réseau Action Climat launched its calculator to measure these extra prices: “In France, the richest 10% consume 10 times more fuel than the poorest 10%”. But are environmental NGOs telling the reality or ‘false’?

“The richest individuals consume 10 times more fuel, primarily as a result of they’ve heavier autos, more SUVs, that are more costly to purchase, but additionally as a result of they care much less about fuel costs.”, Pierre Leflaive, transport supervisor of Réseau Action Climate, helps the interview by Franceinfo. Conversely, “There is a complete section of the inhabitants that’s already calm in its habits, not essentially due to environmental causes, however due to financial constraints, Adds staff. For them, the explosion in fuel costs can value as much as 100 euros further monthly. It’s large.”

To help his feedback, Pierre Leflive depends on a examine revealed on March 22 by Transport and Environment, a Brussels-based NGO, which examines On assessing the effectiveness of fuel tax cuts in Europe.


Fuel Expenditure (Transport and Environment) for First and Last Deciles by European Countries in Euros

The examine presents a desk displaying the first and final diesel fuel prices of 2015 calculated from Eurostat knowledge by European nation on web page 17. In France, this quantity rises to 129 euros per 12 months for the first decile (ie the 10% of the most modest households). And for the final decile (thus the 10% of the richest households), the value is 1,231 euros a 12 months, or really 10 times more. The quantities that appear unusually low, nevertheless: with 129 euros, the poorest motorists may refill about forty liters solely 2.5 times a 12 months, at the value of diesel in 2015, which was a mean of 1.20 euros.

Another downside: the conclusions of the Transport and Environment report don’t match the statistics obtainable in France, famous economist Marc Baudry, a professor at the University of Paris Nanterre. “I can not discover this order on a scale of 1 to 10 between wealthy households and modest households, he instructed franceinfo. I’ve taken family consumption based mostly on an INSEE survey revealed in 2017. In this examine cited by Marc Baudry, the poorest 10% of households spent 628 euros per 12 months on fuel in 2017 in comparison with 1,375 euros for the richest, when a liter of diesel offered for 1.40 euros.

Consumption is twice as excessive amongst rich French individuals, additionally famous Philippe Martin, a member of the Council for Economic Analysis, who revealed a notice on the monetary scenario of households at the begin of the power disaster on Thursday, July 21. “For the month of June, We have 100 euros in fuel prices for the poorest and 200 euros for the richest.” With a diesel value of two.1 euros, confirms the economist with franceinfo.

In brief, the economists in query don’t help the order of magnitude given by the Association Reso Action Climate. On the different hand, they verify that the hole in consumption between well-off and low-income households is critical. As a outcome, there will probably be no discount in fuel costs as decided by the state “reactive”That, warns the Economic Analysis Council, means it’ll first profit the rich, who consume more fuel.

How to tell everybody effectively?

Take half in consultations launched as a part of the European challenge de facto on the platform. Partner Franceinfo